joeware - never stop exploring... :)

Information about joeware mixed with wild and crazy opinions...

Come on Western Digital…

by @ 12:13 am on 12/15/2007. Filed under tech

So I am setting up my new Terabyte MyBook from Western Digital….

Complaints so far

1. The little getting started leaflet basically just says install the CD and use our software…

My problem with that is I hate installing software on my PC that I don’t really want and don’t want that software. So I check my DHCP reservations and sure enough, I find it pops up as MyBookWorld using my scope options… cool. I look in DNS…

2. Doesn’t register its own DNS Address nor ask DHCP to do it for it.

Grrr.

I go to the IP address in a web browser and voila it pops right up. Very cool. I start going through configuration.

3. It asks for an admin ID and password… Great. No clue, the little get started leaflet says nothing about it.

I search the internet and find it in about 33 seconds. Thank you yet again Google. For the curious, the default userid is admin, the default password is 123456

4. For TZ it doesn’t give standard names, it says things like America/Detroit.

Ugh.

So now I try to create a new user, I like to use $joe for anything that will be admin like actions and since this is for backups, that is an admin action.

5. Can’t use anything but letters and numbers for userid….

Come on, really?? Seriously???

So now I say, well I guess I better use joe…

6. Userid has to be between 5 and 20 characters

M u s t  C o n t r o l  B l o o d  P r e s s u r e  :o)

So I choose something else and it has me set the permissions for the default share named PUBLIC. Default permission is none, very good default. I pull up the security sheet for the PUBLIC share.

7. Everyone FULL control…

KAPOW!

8. No mechanism to see who is attached to the NAS.

9. Nothing to see the state of use of space by share.

10. No mechanism to maintain file level permissions via web manager

11. Look at permissions through Windows Explorer and see Everyone Read and Execute and a group called www-data(BACKUP\www-data) with Full Control and a group called www-data(Unix Group\www-data) with Read and Execute…

wtf

12. I can’t monkey with those permissions even though it lets me pick users defined on the NAS. Attempts result in access denied.

So much for this being a cool little small business file server. Not that I needed that, but come on. This wouldn’t have annoyed me as much except for 1-10. To use different perms you need to use different shares. A bit annoying, I like the idea of a single share with permissions on subfolders.

 

Its not all bad, for the money I still think it is a steal and it is pretty fast and a heck of a lot easier than setting up a file server be it Windows or BSD. Also if my house ever catches on fire or starts flooding I can grab it and throw it under my arm and run with it in case the stuff in the fire safe for some reason doesn’t make it.

    joe

Rating 3.00 out of 5

7 Responses to “Come on Western Digital…”

  1. Joe, why not trying Windows Home Server ?
    sure ntfs rights works 😉

  2. The Americas/Detroit, Americas/New_York, etc is standard Linux fare.

    The share permissions sounds like samba funny business.

  3. joe says:

    Mathieu: I didn’t actually go out looking for a storage solution, just stumbled over it and it was so cheap I decided to try it out. I don’t actually need any more Windows Servers, I have probably 20-30 running at any given moment as virtuals. I haven’t looked at Home Server but I doubt there is much it can give me that I haven’t likely set up already that I need.

    Brian: Oh yeah, I am sure it is a LINUX with SAMBA type CIFS emulation package.

  4. Geoff says:

    You didn’t mention the EULA for the drive itself. It’s not too bad, but it wants you to agree to the license without you knowing what the software will do. It seems to just be the software to run the drive, but…

    The EULA for the MioNet software is horrible – you have to agree to let it silently update your machine whenever it wants.

    Thanks for the tips on setting it up. I’m just looking for a “Public” drive for sharing files across five systems in the house, and this looks like it will work acceptably well. There is no default gateway set up, so it’s not going to talk to the world!

  5. Rob Quarters says:

    I have a Drobo, and I must say it has definitely lived up to its marketing hype about “easy to setup”. It literally took me less than 10 minutes and that includes unpacking. NOW… it’s not network attached, and it sounds like many your issues are network related – but the drobo really surprised me…

    Rob

  6. Barryke says:

    I got a WD MyBook World Edition II. (2TB)
    Sports gigabit ethernet, but only manages 4MB per second.

    Plus side is that it runs on linux. If you like exploring jungles you’ve got options there.

  7. Barryke says:

    Forgot: In case you didn’t know here is a community of people toying with adding features to these things: http://mybookworld.wikidot.com/

[joeware – never stop exploring… :) is proudly powered by WordPress.]